When love is torn away: Reflections on loss, faith, and a nation in mourning
Published on September 18, 2025
                We all watched as Erika Kirk was handed the bitter chalice of losing her beloved husband too soon. As I’ve talked to friends, I have found that we’re all experiencing something similar: grief, sadness, despair, exhaustion, weariness. We deeply feel the absence of Charlie’s voice and continue to mourn for the young family he leaves behind.
My personal grief for Erika has caused me to do a lot of reflecting. Her loss is now mixed with my own recent loss. One year ago, four weeks before our wedding, my fiancé unexpectedly died.
Reflecting on those moments after loss
My heart is broken with Erika’s. I am in mourning with her. All of the pain and loss and emptiness of my past year have resurfaced as I’ve been living through these days with her.
I died on that August day. My heart broke beyond repair. The dreams that we had were put to death. The future was empty. I wanted to die, too.
Before my fiancé’s death, I never would have guessed that, in three days, I’d be casket shopping. The plan was to drive to Cincinnati and pick up an antique rug we had bought. But there I was, three days later, sitting in a funeral parlor looking through a catalogue with casket options I knew he would have hated (can anyone get a simple walnut option in those catalogues?)
Decisions needed to be made, plans needed to be canceled, everybody wanted to talk to me, nobody wanted to talk to me, cards to open, ugly Amazon gifts sat awkwardly on the table, flowers filled the room, no appetite, texts stretched a mile. All of it numb. Blurry.
I would never again hug him or hear his laugh or ask for his advice or hear him say “I love you.” I would never call him my husband, and, in death, I don’t get to call myself a widow. Done. Book closed. Final.
Living between the veil
The in-between state of existence is hard to explain. I gave my heart to him, and just because he was dead didn’t mean that I got my heart back. My fiancé continued to hold my gifted heart in his own as he entered Christ’s heart. It was like I was straddling the veil, one foot in the world, one foot in death. Basically, the veil had become quite thin, and my heart was brought close to Christ’s.
Christ did not abandon me. His closeness in my dark hour was the greatest intimacy I’ve ever experienced in my life. I repeatedly told Christ that I was dead, that I didn’t have a heart anymore. In response, He gave me His own heart, breathing life into my shell of a body through the Eucharist and Confession.
The only consolation I received was in prayer. I saw myself in Him at His agony in the garden, in the bloody stripping of His garments, in the carrying of His cross, in His crucifixion. I was helping Christ carry a small share of His burdens like Simon of Cyrene. I offered all that I had to show Him my love, like Veronica offering her veil.
It was a constant battle with utter despair, but God’s grace was persistent. Through this pain, Christ revealed Himself to me in ways I never knew possible.
A nation in despair
There is so much happening in our world today that would be the cause of immense despair. Shootings in Minneapolis and Colorado schools. The random stabbing of an innocent woman on a Charlotte train. The brutal assassination of a leader who desired to pursue truth to the end. The list goes on and on. Enough broken hearts to bring an entire nation to despair.
I’ve heard a lot of questions these last few days.
Where does it end? How many more tragedies are to come? Is anybody safe anymore? Why is all of this happening? Why does God allow such painful things to happen?
I’ve asked myself questions like this more times than I can count in the last year.
Why did he have to die? Why did I have to be the one left behind? Why did it happen before we got married? Why didn’t God save him? Am I being punished for my sins? Will this happen to me again?
This is the truth: Death will happen again and again. We all know this. Some of us die in peace, some in violence, some unexpectedly, some too soon, some too late (I think of my poor 100-year-old grandma who wonders why she’s still alive).
We will never know when or how our lives will come to an end. That was never promised to us. That is not our source of strength. We all need a reminder of what has been promised to us.
Promises made, promises kept
We are promised a life to come. That the “dawn from on high shall break upon us, to shine on those who dwell in darkness and the shadow of death, and to guide our feet into the way of peace.” (Luke 1:78-79) That God will show us greater mercy than we can imagine, and all we must do is humbly desire to receive it. That God is the perfect arbiter of justice. That the peace of Christ can reign inside each of us, even in the darkest of moments, if we turn our hearts and minds to Him.
Many of us look at Erika Kirk, feeling the impossibility and pain of her life now. We dread, on her behalf, the sad days to come. We cannot imagine how anyone could have the strength to go through such a tragedy as this because we are not the ones going through that tragedy. God offers abundant grace to those who are in suffering. Scripture reminds us of this time and time again. The saints write on this extensively. And I speak from my own experience that it is true. God can raise us to new life.
“Beloved, do not be surprised that a trial by fire is occurring among you, as if something strange were happening to you. But rejoice to the extent that you share in the sufferings of Christ, so that when his glory is revealed you may also rejoice exultantly.” (1 Peter 4:12-13)
God might give you more than you can handle
Have you heard the famous saying, “God never gives you more than you can handle?” I hear it all the time from well-meaning people, but it completely misses the point.
God allows trials to come our way that are simply too much for us to bear. Some trials are so great that we are left completely emptied. When we hit rock bottom, we are quickly reminded of how entirely dependent we are on God.
By His grace, we can survive shipwrecks, torture, imprisonment, martyrdom, and the death of a heart. Praise be to God.
Please join me in praying for Erika’s strength, the repose of Charlie’s soul, and hope for a despairing nation.
                                        
                                        
                                        
                                        
Beautiful commentary.
Oh Sarah! Thank you for sharing your heart. What a heavy cross you are carrying. May Our Blessed Lord continue to comfort you and Our Lady’s mantle cover you.
So raw, so true. Thank you for sharing. My husband died two years ago. I knew where to find a simple casket:
https://trappistcaskets.com/
Me too Genevieve. God gave us time before my husband’s passing to think about these things. It was good. It is the unexpected suddeness that takes us unawares.
While grief can break the heart, God’s love is what heals and repairs it. Christ sacrificed His Life for ours, so that like Him, we may enjoy a life that never ends.
Beautiful and encouraging article. I’m so sorry for your loss but great you see Gods blessings in the tragedy.
Beautiful comments. I lost my husband 1 month ago so your commentary hit home
I am sorry for your loss. May he rest in God’s eternal peace.
I’m sorry for your loss. Your thoughts are beautifully expressed. Thank you for sharing your heart with us and reaffirming God’s grace in suffering.
Amen
So sorry for your loss, Sarah! Thank you for sharing from your heart with such a beautifully written article and for your words of wisdom. God bless you!
Thank you for sharing your love story! Pax Domine sit semper tecum.
Thank you for giving words to the pain and poetry of loss. So much truth here.
So beautifully said! Thank you for sharing not only your immense loss but also your deep faith. “Some trials are so great that we are left completely emptied. When we hit rock bottom, we are quickly reminded of how entirely dependent we are on God.”
Sarah, wish I could hug you. 45 years ago my fiance was murdered. My life plans were shattered into pieces but with Gods grace, and His provision of friends, I kept going. I knew my fiancé would’ve wanted me to. I attended the trial of his killer, forgave him.
I was able to start a new chapter in my life, meet a wonderful man.
Keep going, one day at a time knowing Jesus is with you
Thank you for sharing your thoughts and reflections with us! So beautifully written, it’s a blessing. I did marry my husband but then he descended into bad cycles and began physically abusing me, so my love was lost to that. It’s a different pain, but still a grief. I also lost a little daughter at birth (my only girl) so I can identify with the pain of lost possibilities, days and love that never came. God be with you Sarah, and Erika!
Thank you Sarah for sharing your story; your openness give hope to so many; may God bless you and keep you
Words we all need to hear and be reminded of as death is part of life. God Bless you and may he continue to be your source of strength.
Such a beautiful expression of your grief and healing journey and the importance of allowing God to be present for everything. I do believe in the Communion of Saints and when such great sorry and loss strikes the Body of Christ here on earth we all feel the loss, despair, and sorrow deeply. You so beautifully expressed that we need to join this sorry and suffering with Christ’s suffering and rely on God to help us through as individuals, families, nations and the world. God bless you and Erika and all affected by these tragedies.
When i hear or read about what other people have suffered through or are suffering through I’m ashamed of the complaining I do about my “problems” which are trivial in comparison. God bless you keep you and Erika Kirk as well. I will add you to my rosary intention list.
Thank you and I am sending prayers from my daily rosary for you.
God bless you! Thank you for showing your heart and soul dear one.
Amen
Thank you for sharing and reminding us all of what death will bring to life. GOD bless you.
Thank you for that beautiful testimonial.
God bless you &Erica
Thank you for sharing you heart a pain and the glory of God! I can hear awesome love and grace that he has given you to share with those who have experienced what you have. God’s strength is in you! 🙏❤️🙏
Wow, thank you for sharing…this was incredibly honest and hopeful to read. What a gift you have given us, Sarah.
So very well said. My sympathy for both you and Erika and what she is now going through in this senseless tragedy.
Such touching testimony. I was truly blessed by it. Thank you.
This is exceptionally well written. Praying for Erika, but also for you, Sarah.
Twenty-one weeks ago, my son took his own life. The shock and grief, I thought, was unbearable. But with prayer, Mass, communion and confession, I am making it through. It still hurts and, no doubt, will hurt for a long time to come. Thank you, Jesus, for the time we had with him.
I’m so sorry for your loss and all the pain you are going through. Please know you will be prayed for, even though we don’t know one another, we are one in the body of Christ.
Absolutely beautiful!
Thank you so much for sharing your own loss and story and for for helping us to understand and remember that we need always to trust and lean into God’s own heart, especially in pain and loss. You out so beautifully much of what many of us are feeling. Thank you for your courage and your willingness to share your pain to help us all heal. May God continue to bless you and heal you. You will be in my prayers, as will all those who were mentioned.
I lost my nine year old son in 1988. I was deeply mournful and in pain. The only relief I received was through my Catholic faith. I was angry when Charlie was brutally assassinated but prayer, reconciliation and the Eucharist reminded me of the Gospel. God bless you Sarah and Erika with love and peace. So very sorry for your loss.
Profound! Thank you for penning what many of us feel but can’t express so beautifully.
Being a widower, all I can say is this is very well written.
One of the most healing articles on pain and suffering that I have ever read, and I have read many! At 65 I have never been blessed with a husband, which in itself brings me great sadness, but I have experienced great deep and sorrowful sufferings for years, and this article really spoke to my heart and soul. Thank you so very much for your gift of healing. This is something I can truly hold onto. God bless.
We know death was never a part of God’s perfect plan, and yet He sent our dear Jesus for that sole purpose! Thank You so very much Sarah for sharing the intimate indescribable human experience that accompanies loss. You have provided a hope for all of us who will undoubtedly experience this depth of loss, helping us to eventually look beyond the grief, questions, and suffering, to reach the same conclusion, that He will never leave us nor forsake us.
Simply stunning. Thank you for sharing your heart and grief and giving us the ability to pray for and with you.
Thank you for sharing more of your interior darkness and hope with the world, and thank you to you and your beloved for sharing your examples of holiness for us to observe and imitate! May he and Charlie through the mercy of God rest in peace.