Oscar Wilde famously said, “You can never be overdressed or overeducated.” While that sentiment has stood the test of time, we’ve all had moments of hesitation in front of the mirror – Am I doing too much? Will I feel out of place? Should I have put in more effort?

But here’s the truth: what we wear matters. Clothing is more than just fabric and trends; it’s a statement about how we see ourselves and how we present that to the world. Dressing well is an act of self-respect and a way to honor the people and spaces we engage with.

So, which is better – being underdressed or overdressed? Let’s explore.

The case for overdressing: Elevating everyday moments

If you’ve ever arrived at an event feeling like you put in more effort than others, you might have wondered, Did I go too far? But making an effort with your appearance isn’t about standing out unnecessarily—it’s about showing respect for yourself and those around you.

Presentation is powerful

There’s an undeniable confidence that comes with dressing well. Studies show that people perceive well-dressed individuals as more competent, prepared, and even more trustworthy. Whether we like it or not, first impressions matter. Walking into a room polished and put-together sends a message: I value myself and I value this moment.

Dressing well is timeless

Style icons throughout history – from Audrey Hepburn, to Jackie Kennedy, to Kate Middleton – prove that elegance never goes out of fashion. That doesn’t mean wearing ball gowns to the grocery store, it does mean appreciating the power of effort and making even their most casual outfits tasteful and intentional. They show that dressing well isn’t about extravagance – it’s about respect.

Overdressed often just means well-dressed

More often than not, what some might call “overdressed” is simply appropriate. A structured outfit for a casual meeting, a refined look for a family brunch, a polished ensemble for running errands—these choices don’t mean you’ve gone overboard. They mean you care. And, as a general rule, it’s far less uncomfortable to be slightly overdressed than to realize you’re underdressed.

The case for underdressing: When simplicity speaks volumes

For years, the push toward casual fashion was seen as a cultural shift – one that blurred the lines between professional and informal, traditional and modern. But today, many young people are rediscovering the beauty of structure, discipline, and formality – values that previous generations largely moved away from.

At the same time, simplicity can still make a statement. A more understated approach to dressing doesn’t have to mean sloppy or indifferent.

Authenticity over excess

Dressing well doesn’t always mean dressing formally. Simplicity can speak volumes when it is done with care. Not every occasion requires elaborate formality, but every moment benefits from intentionality. The goal is not to reject structure, but to embrace a thoughtful approach to presentation.

The right kind of ease

There’s a difference between dressing with ease and dressing with indifference. One reflects confidence and discernment; the other disregards the significance of the moment. A casual outfit should still be clean, well-fitted, and in good condition – no holes, stains, or excessive wear.

When dressing down works

In daily life, thoughtful simplicity allows for flexibility without losing sight of dignity. A relaxed approach can make space for personal style, but the line should be drawn at carelessness. Ultimately, the line should be drawn at being willfully careless. Choosing to underdress out of laziness or apathy edges towards disrespect for ourselves and others.

The right fit: Dressing for the occasion

How do we avoid the dreaded moment of realizing we’ve miscalculated our wardrobe? The key is reading the room ahead of time and dressing for the people and the place—not just ourselves. A little thought and effort beforehand goes a long way.

• Consider the setting – Is it a wedding, a dinner party, or a work event? Err on the side of dressing up rather than down. Ask or look to see if there’s a dress code or how people typically dress for that event. 
• Respect the host – If someone has invited you into their space (home, church, party) showing effort in your attire is a sign of appreciation.
• Find balance – If you’re unsure, elevate a casual outfit with simple touches: a blazer, a delicate necklace, polished shoes, or intentional layering. A simple yet refined look always works.

The goal isn’t rigid fashion rules. It’s dressing in a way that brings out the best version of yourself while respecting the dignity of the moment.

Dressing as a reflection of your worth

Your clothing is an outward expression of your inner beauty and how you wish to convey it. When we dress thoughtfully, we communicate not only our personality but also our sense of self-worth.

• Dressing well doesn’t mean flashy; it means being intentional
• Elegance and modesty can coexist with personal style
• What we wear is a reflection of our values – whether we mean it to be or not

There’s a reason we dress up for important events. Weddings, job interviews, and Sunday Mass call for an elevated approach – because they matter. Why should we wait for an “important” moment to present ourselves well? Life itself is worthy of effort.

Build a wardrobe that works for every occasion

You don’t need an overflowing closet of expensive pieces to master the balance between underdressing and overdressing. Instead, focus on timeless staples that allow you to transition seamlessly between casual and formal settings.

Essentials for effortless elegance:

• A well-tailored blazer – instantly elevates any outfit from jeans to slip dresses
• A classic little black dress – (or polished monochromatic separates) versatile sophistication (goes with heels and a handbag or flats and a cropped jacket)
• Quality shoes – swapping sneakers for loafers or flats with a causal fit is the easiest upgrade
• Thoughtful accessories – layers show you took the time to make even the simplest look more put-together (scarves, belts, jewelry, a handbag) 
• A go-to outfit formula that you can rely on when in doubt

Remember: It’s not about expense or trends – it’s dressing with care, confidence, and dignity.

When in doubt, choose effort

So, underdressed or overdressed – what’s the better choice?

The best option is dressing with intention. Clothing is a powerful tool for communicating thoughtfulness and grace. At the end of the day, it’s not about impressing others but about showing up for life with the dignity and respect that you—and the moment—deserve.

And if you must choose?

Overdressed wins, every time.

You might also enjoy these articles from Refine!

• Capsule wardrobes: A sustainable solution to fashion overload
• How to maximize your wardrobe without buying anything
• A fresh look at your winter wardrobe